Claim tool →
Storm damage, decided on the math.
Hub · Storms & Insurance

Storm damage,
decided on the math.

Hail, wind, and the insurance claim that follows. When to file, when not to, how to read an adjuster scope before you sign — and the documentation that actually changes outcomes.

Should I file a claim?Find a roofer

When does a storm-damage claim pencil out?

When expected repair cost exceeds your deductible plus a 20-30% premium-bump cushion. Most carriers raise wind/hail premium 8-12% for 3-5 years after a paid claim. A $4,000 claim with $2,500 deductible nets you ~$1,500 today against ~$1,600-$2,400 in future premium. Use the insurance claim tool for the exact math by carrier and state.

The break-even framework

The question is not “is the damage real?” The question is “does filing leave me net positive over a 5-year window?” The variables: expected repair cost, deductible (especially wind/hail percentage deductibles, which are large), your carrier’s premium-bump pattern (8-12% on the wind/hail peril for 3-5 years is typical), your prior claim count in C.L.U.E. (one claim is fine; two within 3 years is non-renewal territory in soft markets), and your time horizon (planning to move in 18 months changes the math).

The first 72 hours after a storm

Document before you clean up. Date-stamped photos from multiple angles, both ground-level and aerial if accessible. Then put a tarp on any active leak — your policy obligates you to mitigate, but does not obligate you to repair before the adjuster sees the damage.

Note the NOAA event. Look up your address on the NOAA Storm Events database to confirm a recorded hail or high-wind event. Adjusters cross-reference this; an unrecorded event makes the claim much harder.

Get a contractor damage report. Not a quote — a report on contractor letterhead documenting damage, location, severity, and probable cause. Most reputable roofers will do this for $0-$300; many do it free in the hope of winning the replacement work.

Read your policy — specifically the “duties after loss” clause and the “wind/hail deductible” section. Filing windows vary 60 days–1 year; deductibles can be percentage-based.

Common questions

File when expected repair cost exceeds your deductible plus a 20-30% premium-bump cushion. Most carriers raise wind/hail premium 8-12% for 3-5 years after a paid claim, so a $4,000 claim with a $2,500 deductible nets you ~$1,500 today against ~$1,600-2,400 of future premium. Use the insurance claim tool for the exact math.
Most homeowner policies require notice within 1 year of the loss; some carriers/states shorten to 60-180 days specifically for hail. The clock starts the day damage occurred — not the day you noticed it. Check your specific policy under "duties after loss." Texas specifically caps the filing window at 1 year by statute (TX Insurance Code §542A.005).
Date-stamped photos of damage from multiple angles, a NOAA-confirmed hail event near your address (lat/long + date), a contractor damage report on letterhead, your roof age + last inspection records, and any prior claims. Carriers cross-reference NOAA Storm Events to verify the event occurred. Photos shot AFTER any cleanup or temporary repair are weaker.
Compare line by line — usually the adjuster missed slopes, undersized the underlayment scope, or used outdated unit prices. Submit a "supplement" with the contractor's detailed scope + line-item Xactimate pricing. If the gap is large (40%+) and persistent, hire a public adjuster — they take 10-15% of the claim but typically recover 2-4× their fee on a contested claim.
In most states, a single weather-related claim cannot legally trigger non-renewal or cancellation. Multiple claims (especially within 3 years) can. Wind/hail claims paid out are reported to the C.L.U.E. database, which other carriers will see if you shop. The non-renewal risk is real but is dominated by claim count, not single-claim filing.
Increasingly common in hail-belt and hurricane-belt states (CO, TX, OK, FL, LA). Instead of a flat $1,000-2,500 deductible, the wind/hail peril uses 1-5% of dwelling coverage — on a $400k home, that's $4,000-20,000 deductible specifically for storm claims. Materially changes the file-vs-don't-file math. Verify in your policy declarations.

Answers

Plain-English answers from this hub.

Focused answer pages on the questions readers actually ask. 40-60 word atomic answer plus 600-900 words of context.

Run the numbers

Use the insurance claim tool.

Address + roof age + last damage event → hit-probability score, deductible-vs-repair break-even, and a documentation checklist sized to your specific claim.

Open the claim tool → →Find a roofer